Blog · Technique
How to start a debate speech (and how not to)
3rd Best APDA Debater · TOC Semifinalist · Columbia Debate Society Coach
Judges form an impression of a speech in its first thirty seconds, and most beginners spend those seconds on throat-clearing: greetings, restating the motion word for word, a quotation someone told them was classy. The fix is knowing what each speech's opening is for. There are only three jobs an opening can have, and they map onto the three kinds of speech in a round.
Opening the first speech: define the debate
The first speaker for each side owns the framing. The opening must do three things fast: state your side, tell the judge what this debate is really about, and preview your case. For a motion like “This House would ban homework”:
“We propose. This debate is not about whether practice matters; it is about whether after-school hours belong to schools or to families. We will prove two things: that homework's learning benefit is small and unequal, and that its cost to childhood is large and universal.”
Twenty seconds, and the judge now has a lens for the whole round, your lens. The full framing toolkit (definitions, the split, the winning metric) is in our first speaker essay.
Opening a middle speech: pivot off the clash
Second speeches and later must not open with prepared material. The judge just heard the other side; the opening that earns attention is the one that engages it immediately. Name the biggest thing your opponents said, then flag what you will do to it:
“The previous speaker's whole case rests on one claim, that homework is the only scalable form of practice. In the next minute I will show you it is neither the only form nor a working one, and then rebuild our argument about family time, which went completely unanswered.”
That opening signposts rebuttal, promises rebuilding, and quietly tells the judge an argument was dropped. The mechanics of the rebuttal that follows are in the rebuttal guide and the second speaker essay.
Opening a closing speech: zoom out
Closing speeches (the third speaker, and the reply in formats that have one) open by shrinking the round. Not “I will respond to everything,” but:
“This round has come down to two questions: does homework actually teach, and who should control a child's evening? We've won the first on the evidence and they have barely contested the second. Let me show you both.”
Organizing a messy round into two or three named clashes is the whole craft of the closing chairs; the whip speech essay and the reply speech essay teach it in full.
The three classic ways to waste thirty seconds
The ceremonial opening (“Good afternoon judges, honorable opponents…”), the dictionary opening (“Webster defines homework as…”), and the borrowed-gravitas opening (an inspirational quote with no argumentative work to do). All three delay the moment the judge starts hearing your case, and none earns speaker points in any modern format. Cut them, open on the job your speech exists to do, and practice it: pull a motion from the topics page, give yourself five minutes of prep, and deliver just the first minute, three times, three different ways. It is the cheapest drill in debate and the fastest one to show up in scores.
Common questions
How do you write an opening statement for a debate?
+
State your side, define the debate on your terms, and preview your arguments, in that order and inside a minute. A serviceable template: "We stand in proposition of this motion. This debate comes down to [the real question]. We will prove two things: first, [argument one]; second, [argument two]." Polish comes later; clarity wins now.
Should I open a debate speech with a hook or a quote?
+
A one-line hook that frames the actual clash can work. A memorized quotation, a dictionary definition, or a rhetorical question usually costs more than it buys, because judges are listening for the debate to be defined, not decorated. If a hook does not make your side easier to vote for, cut it.
How long should the opening of a speech be?
+
Thirty to sixty seconds for a first speech: side, framing, preview, then into the first argument. Later speeches should open even faster, because their first job is responding to what was just said, and every second spent on ceremony is a second of rebuttal lost.
Openings are a drill, not a gift.
Students in our classes rehearse speech openings weekly, in judged rounds, until the first thirty seconds run on rails.