Motion Bank · By topic

Medical Ethics & Health debate motions

From euthanasia to vaccine mandates to organ markets, these motions stage the oldest clash in ethics: individual autonomy against collective welfare, played out on the human body. They are common at every level from novice rounds to Worlds finals.

703 motions, newest season first, verbatim from tournament records. Info slides are included where the tournament released one. For keyword search and shuffle drills, use the searchable bank.

2026 (8 motions)

  • This House, as the leadership of a major news organisation (e.g., The Economist, CBS, The Washington Post), would adopt moralised journalism as a stance

    WUDC 2026 · Round 3

    Info slide

    "Moralised journalism" refers to media outlets taking an explicit moral or values-driven approach in their reporting. Such outlets would take a clear and consistent stance on the issues they cover. This may include coverage that emphasises moral outrage, the use of emotionally charged language, and links to broader social narratives.

  • This House regrets the use of drastic state interventions to address the COVID-19 pandemic (e.g., prolonged mass lockdowns, school closures, vaccine mandates)

    WUDC 2026 · Semifinals

  • THP a world where all high-stakes life decisions (e.g., career path, choice of spouse, medical treatment) are made by a perfectly objective AI, rather than by individuals.

    South East Asia Debating Championship 2026 · Novice Grand Final

  • THW only allow surrogacy in cases of medical necessity

    1st Cebu Novice AP 2026 · Round 1

  • THR the romanticization of "organic encounter"

    1st Cebu Novice AP 2026 · Novice Grand Final

    Info slide

    An organic encounter in dating is the act of meeting a potential partner naturally in the real world, without the assistance of apps, websites, or algorithms. These meetings typically occur spontaneously during everyday life, such as being introduced by a mutual friend, striking up a conversation at a coffee shop, or connecting through a shared hobby.

  • This house believes that news organisations should prioritise "slow journalism" over real-time reporting

    Asia Pacific Schools DC 2026 · Round 2

    Info slide

    Slow journalism is a news model that prioritises depth, verification, and long-form investigation over rapid, real-time updates. It produces fewer, more thoroughly researched stories, avoiding breaking-news style reporting.

  • This House would legalize commercial organ selling.

    Korea Junior Nationals 2026 · U14 Main Semifinals

    Info slide

    Commercial organ selling refers to the legal buying and selling of human organs (such as kidneys or liver segments) for transplantation, typically involving financial compensation for the donor.

  • In deadlocked conflicts against insurgent organizations, THS states adopting conciliatory measures over belligerent measures

    Malaysian National Schools DC 2026 · Semifinals

    Info slide

    A conciliatory measure is an action, gesture, or policy intended to reduce tension, settle a dispute, or win over an opposing party. E.g amnesty and political concessions. Belligerent measures refer to hostile, aggressive, or warlike actions taken by a state. E.g increased military productions and forced conscription.

2025 (12 motions)

  • This House Believes that the student organisers of the July Revolution should not transition into formal political roles (e.g., run for elected office, form their own political party)

    Panama WUDC 2025 · Round 5

    Info slide

    The July Revolution was a mass popular student-led uprising that ousted Bangladesh's ruling Awami League government and led to the establishment of a politically neutral interim government. The student organisers of the uprising have since occupied important positions within the interim government and founded the National Citizen's Committee (Jatiyo Nagorik Committee), a non- affiliated platform aimed at "building a democractic Bangladesh". Many of the student organisers were previously involved in political organising under the banners of various political parties.

  • This House Opposes the narrative that doctors know best.

    Copenhagen EUDC 2025 · Round 4

  • THO the medicalization of gender dysphoria among the queer community

    Guangzhou UADC 2025 · Octofinals

    Info slide

    Medicalization is the process of defining a phenomenon through medical language in order to categorize it as one that can be treated by medical services (eg. gender affirming services).

  • TH, as the South Korean LGBTQIA+ movement, W significantly prioritize provinces outside of Seoul in their advocacy (ie. organizing larger pride parades in provinces, financially supporting provincial queer organizations, etc.)

    Guangzhou UADC 2025 · Octofinals

  • THBT research organisations in the Global South should prioritise South-to-South collaborations instead of partnering with institutions in the Global North

    PAUDC 2025 · Partial Quarter Finals

  • This house believes that true womxn's liberation is incompatible with the existence of organized religion

    Ziauddin University DC 2025 · Round 4

  • This House believes that drug or alcohol rehabilitation services provided by religious organizations bring more harm than good

    Seasons Pre-WSDC 2025 · Semifinals

  • This house would make Organ Donation mandatory for every citizen around the world.

    Asia Junior Championships Winter 2025 · U14 Semifinals

    Info slide

    In the status quo, individuals have the option to either sign up to be an organ donor where, once they die, their organs are made available to be used by ones who might be able to use them or an individual can opt out as well from donating their organ.

  • This house believes that the final say in the medical treatment of minors should belong to medical professionals (doctors) instead of parents

    Australasian Junior DC 2025 · Round 4

    Info slide

    A minor means someone under 18 years old (a child or teenager who is not yet an adult). In many countries, parents normally make the final decision about their child's medical treatment (like surgery or medicine)

  • This house believes that government should not provide healthcare services to those who lead an unhealthy life.

    Korea Junior Nationals 2025 · U13 Semifinals

    Info slide

    An unhealthy lifestyle includes poor diet, lack of exercise, and harmful habits like smoking or excessive alcohol consumption. This often leads to serious health issues such as obesity and heart disease.

  • This House supports the use of conscious non-consent by medical professionals in emergency medicine

    Gauteng Open 2025 · Round 3

    Info slide

    Conscious non-consent is a practice in which medical professionals acknowledge that a patient has refused a particular treatment or procedure in the past but proceed to administer said treatment or procedure anyway because it is necessary to preserve the patient's life (e.g. blood transfusions, resuscitation).

  • This would prioritise partnerships between healthcare providers and digital platforms to provide accurate and comprehensive sexual health information to young people.

    Battle of Minds Open 2025 · Secondary Semifinals

2024 (9 motions)

  • That we support a requirement for US state medical boards to be made up of a majority of non-doctors.

    Jakarta Australs 2024 · ESL Semifinals

    Info slide

    US state medical boards are responsible for licencing doctors and investigating complaints made against them. Where a doctor is found to have committed malpractice, the board is empowered to discipline them, including through the suspension or revocation of their medical licences.

  • That we oppose the attempts of civil organisations in South Korea to inform North Korean citizens about their regime's wrongdoings (e.g. disseminating leaflets and ad balloons, smuggling USBs, transmitting cross-border radio waves).

    Jakarta Australs 2024 · Round 7

  • Assuming Feasibility, This House Believes that Artificial Intelligence (AI) should be allowed to make life-and-death decisions in healthcare, including triage and end-of-life care, rather than leaving such decisions to human doctors and families.

    PAUDC Kampala 2024 · Octofinals

  • That we prefer a public option healthcare system to a single payer healthcare system

    UQ Easters 2024 · Quarterfinals

    Info slide

    A 'public option' healthcare system involves the government directly providing public healthcare for vulnerable members of the population (poor people, disabled people, old people etc) for free. The rest of the population may choose to buy into that public system for a fee. A 'single payer' healthcare system involves the government directly providing public healthcare for the entire population.

  • THBT China should use violent force to crackdown on organised crime in the Golden Triangle

    Krabi ABP 2024 · Round 2

    Info slide

    The Golden Triangle is a hotbed of criminal activity at the border of Laos, China, Thailand, and Myanmar. It is one of the world's largest drug trafficking corridors both into and out of China, hosting scam centers, illegal gambling operations, and human trafficking dens. Most illicit activity is centered in a Special Economic Zone protected by Laos' government where large organised crime groups from Mainland China are allowed to operate casinos, some of which are rumored to have ties to high-ranking CCP officials. The Thai army polices the border both to curtail crime and to secure its territorial claim.

  • THS university student representative organisations taking stances on political issues (e.g. student councils organising anti-government protests, having student representatives speak at political rallies etc.)

    Malaysia National Schools WSDC 2024 · Open Octo Finals

  • This House, as the doctor, Would abandon RMS Titanic to board the last lifeboat

    English College Open 2024 · Novice GF

    Info slide

    The year is 1912. You have just completed 8 years of education to obtain your medical degree and surgical license. You are looking forward to a lifetime of operating on patients to save lives, as that is a dream you've had since early childhood, one of your deep passions. Fresh out of med-school, the first job you get is to be a medic on RMS Titanic. You bring your only child along with you for a trip to New York while your wife stays at home, eagerly waiting for your safe return. Four days into the voyage the Titanic hits an iceberg that causes it to start sinking. All chaos breaks loose when it is discovered that there are not enough lifeboats to carry all passengers. In the midst of all the people pushing and shoving to get a spot on a lifeboat, your son gets heavily injured. Due to the extent of his injuries, your son is refused a spot on the lifeboat because they are prioritizing healthy passengers with a higher chance of survival. You yourself however, get offered a spot on the last lifeboat because the passengers said they'll have a higher chance of survival with a doctor onboard. You are aware the Titanic has sent out a distress signal calling on other ships to come help, however you do not know whether or not anyone has answered the call.

  • THS the decline of organised religion in favour of new age mysticism.

    Gauteng Open 2024 · Round 3

  • Except in conditions of drought or famine, THBT International organizations should prioritize cash aid over food aid.

    Uganda National Speech and Debate Championship 2024 · Round 3

    Info slide

    Food aid involves the direct distribution of food products to individuals or communities in need through food banks, community programs, etc. Cash aid involves directly providing financial assistance to individuals or households either directly through their bank accounts or through the accounts of intermediary NGOs.

2023 (12 motions)

  • This House believes that it is against the interest of organized religion to emphasize strict requirements for personal religious commitments (e.g. not being allowed to work on Sabbath, not eating during Ramadan, restraining from premarital relationships, etc.)

    WSDC 2023 · Octofinals (impromptu) · World Schools Debating Championships

  • THBT religious organisations should syncretise over remaining independent

    Madrid WUDC 2023 · EFL Finals

    Info slide

    Religious Syncretism is the practice of blending cultural/religious indigenous practices with different religious beliefs (for example, the Catholic Church merging traditional saints with local deities in Latin America). Religious Independence is the belief that one's religion must remain tied to a unique set of religious teachings that contain the truth about humanity and divinity.

  • This House Prefers drug regulatory bodies (e.g. FDA, EMA, MHRA) to only evaluate whether pharmaceuticals (e.g. treatments, medicines, vaccines) are safe, but not whether they are effective

    Black Sea EUDC 2023 · Round 7

  • This house would legalize active non-voluntary euthanasia.

    HWS Round Robin 2023 · Round 3, Round 3

    Info slide

    Active euthanasia is where proactive steps are taken to hasten someone's death with the aim of minimizing suffering. Non-voluntary euthanasia involves patients not competent to consent (e.g., those in a coma, with dementia, etc.), where someone else consents to hastening their death. If a patient has (while competent) officially filed an "advance directive" about hastening their death under their current health circumstances, then this is NOT a case of non-voluntary euthanasia.

  • THBT hospitals should have the power to remove patients from the care of their legal guardians in suspected 'medical negligence' cases.

    NEADC 2023 · Pre-Quarterfinals

    Info slide

    'Medical negligence' refers to the failure of a carer to provide a standard level of care, resulting in harm or injury to a patient. This could include forgetting to administer medication, choosing a different treatment plan than what was prescribed, or breaching duty of care.

  • TH opposes the trend of charitable organizations increasingly adopting 'resume padding' in their initiative and advocacy.

    NEADC 2023 · Round 1

    Info slide

    'Resume padding' of charity refers to the strategic involvement of individuals, particularly students, in charitable activities with the primary goal of enhancing their resumes rather than a genuine desire to contribute to the cause. This practice has become increasingly common among students seeking to bolster their college applications, as admissions committees often view participation in charity work favourably.

  • THR the narrative that doctors are heroes.

    Ziauddin University DC 2023 · Semifinals

  • THW Ban Nationally Owned or Nationally Linked Organisations from Owning and Sponsoring Sports Clubs

    Malaysian National Universities DC 2023 · Round 3

  • THW legalise the sale of organs

    Asia Pacific WSDC 2023 · Round 1

  • THR the rise of health and medical influencers in social media platforms

    Philippine Schools DC 2023 · Round 3

  • This House Believes That the environmental movement should prioritize advocating for radical individual lifestyle change over solutions by organizations and/or institutions.

    Australasians Junior Championship 2023 · U11 Semifinals

    Info slide

    Some examples of the changes of lifestyle can be, including but not limited to, vegan diets, limited air travel, recycling, reusing, and composting, etc. Some examples of organizational and/or institutional responsibility can be, including but not limited to, carbon capture technologies, reducing pollution, waste, natural resource consumption, and emissions through its manufacturing process, as applicable, etc.

  • That medical staff should be able to opt out of providing treatments on religious or ethical grounds.

    Korea National Championships 2023 · Round 5

    Info slide

    Medical staff may opt out of providing treatments on religious or ethical grounds, such as objections to procedures like abortions or medications that conflict with their beliefs. For example, some may object to certain procedures such as abortions or assisted suicide, on the basis of religious teachings or ethical principles that prohibit taking a human life.

2022 (8 motions)

  • This House Regrets the decline of the family as the dominant unit of organisation in society

    WSDC 2022 · Round 4 (impromptu) · World Schools Debating Championships

  • This House Opposes the trend toward freelance journalism at the expense of traditional employment in a singular media organisation

    Zagreb EUDC 2022 · Round 8

  • A: That we would allow doctors to override advance care directives

    Campbelltown Australs 2022 · ESL Grand Final

    Info slide

    A: An Advance Care Directive (ACD) is a legal document in which a person of sound mind specifies what actions should be taken for their health if they are no longer able to make decisions for themselves (because of illness or incapacity). Doctors are legally required to uphold the instructions of an ACD, irrespective of their professional medical opinions.

  • TH, as a student applying to Ivy League universities, would opt into an already established and successful social non-profit organization instead of making a new one

    Asia Pacific WSDC 2022 · Round 1

    Info slide

    The Ivy League, comprised of Harvard, Yale, Princeton, University of Pennsylvania (UPenn), Dartmouth, Cornell, Columbia, and Brown, are known to be eight of the most renowned private universities in the United States. They are all highly competitive, with the highest acceptance rate in 2022 being 6.9% (Cornell University) and the lowest being 3.2% (Harvard University).

  • THBT the rise in popularity of "healthism", in the countries with private healthcare, brings more harm than good

    Polish Schools DC 2022 · Semifinals

    Info slide

    "Healthism" is the idea that a person's health is entirely their responsibility and moral obligation. It includes stressing the importance of personal dietary and lifestyle decisions on an individual's physical and mental health and wellbeing. This narrative promotes, among other things: the significance of physical activity (e.g. fitness), awareness and use of diets, the practice of yoga/meditation, as well as the use of preventive medicines and suplements to support one's own immune system.

  • THW not allow terminally ill patients to choose alternative medicine in hospitals.

    Asia Junior Championships 2022 · Semifinals

    Info slide

    "Terminally ill patients are patients who are sick and have very low rates of surviving their illness or disease. Examples of such include, late stage cancer patients. Alternative medicine is any practice that aims to achieve the healing effects of medicine, but is untested scienctifically or is proven ineffective. Traditional practices, such as traditional Chinese medicine, become ""alternative"" when used without the guidance of a medical profession"

  • THS the creation and operation of Recovery from Religion organisations in developing countries.

    Malaysia National Schools BP 2022 · Semifinals

  • THW deny people who practises unhealthy lifestyle (i.e smoking, unhealthy eating) access to public healthcare

    Asia Novice Debate Open 2022 · Semifinals

2021 (143 motions)

  • Assuming free consent was given, THW permits people to participate in the Octopus Game.

    DTU PD 2021 · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    In the Octopus Game, players participate in a series of games in pursuit of winning a massive pool of money, that would make them and all their descendants financially independent. If they lose a game, they die.

  • THBT the portrayal of "autistic genius" characters in media do more harm than good. (Example: The leading autistic doctor in "The Good Doctor")

    AUDP Parliamentary Debate · 2

  • THW introduce racial quotas for healthcare professionals (e.g. nurses, doctors)

    Cambridge IV 2021 · 2

  • THW ban research into automated treatments of mental health conditions.

    19th Annual Premchand Debates 2021 · 1

    Info slide

    UCSF researchers implanted a chip that would electronically stimulate the brain of a chronically depressed patient when it registered the chemical onset of depressive episodes.

  • THP to live as a support rather than a carry

    7th Visayas University Debate Championship 2021 · 3

    Info slide

    Supports provide utility (heals, protection, aura effects) to aid their carry in fights or assists in getting objectives and win the game. They usually deal the least damage in the game. Carries are meant to win the game for the team by earning resources (gold, items, levels) enough to deal the most damage and "carry" their team to victory.

  • THBT animal rights advocacy should be targeted at people to change their preference for meat, rather than at corporations/businesses to adopt close meat substitutes (e.g., convincing restaurants to sell plant-based meat, funding research into cell-based meat alternatives).

    Satyam Jha Memorial ProAm Debate 2021 · 3

  • THW agressively fund the research into human cloning

    The Grand Spar November 2021 · 3

    Info slide

    Human cloning is the creation of a genetically identical copy (or clone) of a human. The term is generally used to refer to artificial human cloning, which is the reproduction of human cells and tissue. It does not refer to the natural conception and delivery of identical twins. If you are cloned, you have no memory of a past life.

  • THW introduce 'anti-vaccine' taxes

    The DCAC Fundraiser Open 2021 · 4

    Info slide

    Anti-vaccine taxes will require those unvaccinated against Covid-19 [excluding those who had medical conditions preventing them to] to pay a surcharge while entering and using public spaces like restaurants, (public transport) etc. Clarification : For the purpose of this debate, those who remain unvaccinated do so entirely out of choice (as opposed to say inaccesibility). (This is not an entirely unrealistic assumption, because of where the motion is situated)

  • When medical resources are highly limited, THW prioritise the vaccinated

    HWS IV 2021 · 1

  • THS the increasing privatisation of medical education in India

    Munaazrah Gender & Sexual Minorities Parliamentary Debates 2021 · 4

  • THW lift the corporate veil in all mass tort cases

    Munaazrah Gender & Sexual Minorities Parliamentary Debates 2021 · 4

    Info slide

    The "corporate veil" is a legal concept that maintains the legal separation between the company and its shareholders— the company is a juristic person with its own rights and duties, and the ability to enter into contracts with persons or other institutions, to buy property in its name or take loans. The shareholders and managers are not liable for the company's debts, actions or obligations. However, courts sometimes recognise that artificial persons cannot commit illegal or fraudulent activities, and in exceptional cases lifts this shield of separation and holds the human agents constituting the company liable. This is called the lifting/piercing of the corporate veil. A tort is simply a "wrongful action" that may be caused unintentionally or negligently. A mass tort is an act or an omission that harms or injures multiple people. In such a lawsuit multiple plaintiffs who are harmed or injured in the same/similar manner by the act of the defendant(s), sues the latter for compensation.

  • Assuming empathy could be accurately measured, this house would restrict voting to individuals with a high level of empathy for those outside of their immediate circl

    ABP 2021 · 2

  • This house regrets the rise of shows/films which involve mental suffering and self-harm (e.g. Bojack Horseman, Black Swan, 13 Reasons Why)

    UADC 2021 · EFL_Quarter

  • TH, as the parent, would not give their consent

    UADC 2021 · Open_Octa

    Info slide

    The world is in ruin and has long been corrupted. You are the single parent of a young child who would be the only cure for a virus threatening to infect mankind with a rabid disease. Your child must be killed in order for the cure to be extracted and save the human race. The procedure requires your consent.

  • In a state with failing adoption homes/numbers This House would put a moratorium on IVF clinics

    UADC 2021 · 8

  • This house believes that universities should not accept research funding and scholarships from corrupted / problematic organizations and donors

    UADC 2021 · 1

  • THS personal laws

    Shri Ram Pre-ABP 2021 · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Personal laws are governed by religious scriptures of various communities. They regulate relations arising out of certain factors like marriage, blood and afinity connecting two or more persons. These laws govern over aspects of marriage, divorce, guardianship, maintainance etc.

  • THBT Private colleges and universities that require all students to receive a covid19 vaccination should not have to grant religious exemptions

    Hollatz Debates 2021 · Open_Final

  • THBT medical decisions regarding the life threatening conditions of children should be taken by medical professionals instead of parents

    Juniors Asia Debate Championship 2021 · Silver_Final

  • THR the medicalisation* of mental health. *Medicalisation of mental health refers to the increasing trend of treating mental health phenomena with medicines and the perception of mental health phenomena as medical conditions.

    NALSAR IV 2021 · Novice_Semi

  • Assuming feasibility, TH, as the doctor would anonymously leak the information

    SMU Hammers 2021 · 2

    Info slide

    You are a pro choice doctor who performs abortions. A prominent pro life advocate has come to you in private to ask for an abortion for their unwanted pregnancy. They have asked for this information to be kept under wraps

  • TH, as Gavidia, Would have declined the position

    Wolce Pre-Asians 2021 · Open_Semi

  • THBT in countries with social healthcare systems, the government should not cover medical expenses for individuals who do not take preventive measures to take care of their own health

    Wolce Pre-Asians 2021 · 1

  • THBT it is immoral to donate to animal welfare charities

    Wolce Pre-Asians 2021 · 1

  • THBT controlled substances used to treat mental health conditions (e.g., marijuana, LSD, Oxycodone, Ketamine, Ritalin) should be available upon demand and regardless of diagnosis to any consumer who can demonstrate informed consent

    Wolce Pre-Asians 2021 · 1

  • TH would opt for the Social Security Health System over Universalist Health System in developed countries

    CMDLP 2021 · 9

    Info slide

    For the purposes of this debate, there are two health system models: In the Social Security System, the citizen pays a mandatory fee to the State, which transfers this money to non-governmental organizations that operate the plans. Citizens can choose between different health plans, all of which meet minimum prerequisites (primary care, accidents, common illnesses) and choose the hospitals and areas where they want to allocate their money. The fee that the citizen pays is proportional to the chosen plan. In the Universalist System, funding comes from the State Budget, which operates the health system. The amount transferred to the health area is defined by the government. Any individuals in the country have full access to all areas of health.

  • THBT human rights should be granted to all AI that can pass the test

    BDC Fempowerment 2021 · Open_Quarter

    Info slide

    The Turing test, originally called the imitation game by Alan Turing in 1950, is a test of a machine's ability to exhibit intelligent behaviour equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, that of a human

  • THS universities refusing donations from individuals, organizations and corporations that they deem immoral.

    KIDA 2021 · 1

  • THW ban aid organizations from using images of graphic suffering in their campaigns without the consent of all subjects

    Oceania Queer Open 2021 · 2

  • That sports associations where the sports have caused sportspeople to develop CTE should be forced to compensate the players regardless of whether they could have foreseen that player developing CTE.

    Oceania Queer Open 2021 · 1

    Info slide

    Chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) is a progressive and fatal brain disease associated with repeated traumatic brain injuries (TBIs), including concussions and repeated blows to the head. It is also associated with the development of dementia. Studies have shown that people who experience TBI in early to midlife are two to four times more at risk of developing dementia in late life. This risk appears to be much higher in people with several TBIs, although more research is needed to confirm this. CTE has been demonstrated to have occurred at high levels in sports such as rugby, wrestling, and American football that involve frequent head trauma

  • TH, as an HIV+ individual with an undetectable viral load, would not tell their prospective partners about their HIV status

    Asia Schools Debate Championship 2021 · Open_Z

    Info slide

    Recent studies suggest that a person living with HIV who is able to achieve an undetectable viral load status cannot transmit the virus to others through sexual contact. An undetectable viral load status can be maintained by taking antiretroviral drugs regularly.

  • THW deny state-sponsored healthcare for those who refuse to get vaccinated

    Asia Schools Debate Championship 2021 · 5

  • THW ban the use of Smart Drugs for non-medical purposes in schools

    Asia Schools Debate Championship 2021 · 1

    Info slide

    Smart drugs refer to drugs that improve the cognitive function of individuals, such as memory, creativity

  • THW legalise assisted suicide

    PIDC 2021 · 5

  • THR the rise of care bots

    PIDC 2021 · 5

    Info slide

    Care bots are an emerging breed of robotics catered to the specialized care of the elderly and individuals who face cognitive or social decline. These robots perform the work done by human caregivers including setting medicine reminders, guiding individuals to the bathroom, and contacting loved ones in the case of an emergency.

  • THBT the Nobel Committee should revoke Abiy Ahmed's Nobel prize

    PIDC 2021 · 4

  • In rationing life-saving medical care, THW use the standard of preventability of condition by the individual, rather than quality of life or survivability

    Rahat Fundraiser 2021 · Open_Y

  • THW use the Sweden Pill in Country X

    Doxbridge IV 2021 · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Political Scientist Michael Walzer constructs a thought experiment in which the Swedish government 'had in its possession a wondrous chemical which, if introduced into the water supply of Country X, would turn all citizens, elites and masses, into Swedish-style social democrats.' These Country X citizens face 'a military dictatorship and a religious "republic," without civil and political liberties, and brutally repressive, not only because a new political elite has established itself and resists all challenges but also because women have been returned to their traditional religious subordination to patriarchal authority.' The pill would 'provide them with the knowledge, capacity, and will to create a new regime in which basic security rights, political and civil liberties too, would be respected, women would be treated as equals and so on.' He finds such an intervention to be morally unacceptable, 'as the historical religion and politics of the people' in which the authoritarian government is grounded, 'are values for the people of Country X.'

  • TH, as the Israeli government, would officially acknowledge all kinds of conscientious objection

    Nagoya Debate Open 2021 · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    A "conscientious objector" is an individual who has claimed the right to refuse to perform military service on the grounds of freedom of thought, conscience, or religion. The Israeli government has been sentencing the objectors (sarvanim in Hebrew) to prison for evading service, although with varying durations.

  • THBT prominent liberal figures of gender minorities should not speak out about their regret after choosing to undergo significant medical procedures they advocated for (e.g. feminist activists regretting getting abortions, trans individuals regretting sex reassignment, etc.)

    Mayon Open Debate Cup 2021 · Open_Quarter

  • THW allow terminally ill patients to access experimental drugs (ie drugs that have not completed clinical trials)

    Mayon Open Debate Cup 2021 · Open_Octa

  • THBT microcredit does more harm than good

    BDIDF International Final · OIC)Final

    Info slide

    Microcredit involves providing small loans to individuals, typically in developing countries, who lack access to traditional banking services by lowering eligibility requirements, no collateral, and smaller loaning amounts. Microcredit programs often target women and marginalized communities.

  • This house believes that individuals should only donate to charities that are scored highly by Effective Altruism

    BDIDF Bangladesh · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Effective altruism is a philosophy, and social movement that attempts to apply evidence and reason to determining the most effective ways to improve the world. It often has a focus on lives saved per amount donated, based on numerical, target based goals. For example - Effective Altruism says it's better to purchase malaria vaccines for 5 children, than provide end of life care to a child with a terminal illness,

  • THBT the media should not report on the mental health of those accused of crimes

    SASDC 2021 · Open_Octa

  • In countries with private healthcare, THS the creation of hospitals with free healthcare where there's a random chance patients participate in government research trials in addition to receiving treatment.

    KCL Open · 4

  • This house supports the manufacture of cheap, generic versions of medications and vaccines, in violation of western patents.

    ANU Spring · 0

  • THP a centralised system of healthcare charity

    RMPD · 4

    Info slide

    A centralised system of healthcare charity is a system where one central charity is responsible for the collection and distribution of all financial resources. They would allocate resources based on the number of people affected by each disease.

  • THBT the results of unethical research should be destroyed

    Trinity Open · Open_Octa

  • TH, as Elle Woods, would not accept the offer to go to Harvard

    Law and Justice Open · 2

    Info slide

    Elle Woods is a fashion merchandising student from southern California. Her longterm undergraduate boyfriend, Warner Huntington III, has recently broken up with her because he intends to study at Harvard Law School and become a politician, telling Elle that she is "not serious enough" for that kind of life. Elle was expecting Warner to propose and intending to accept. In response, Elle spent months studying, scoring near-perfect score on the Law School Admission Test, and graduated with a 4.0 average. She has been accepted into Harvard Law School

  • THBT war journalists should be required to render reasonable assistance to the victims, even where it directly jeopardizes their coverage

    Chun Ling InterSchool · Open_Final

  • THR the narrative that time heals all wounds

    Chun Ling InterSchool · 4

  • In countries where abortion is legal and accessible, THW allow fathers to opt out of legal obligations and rights to an unwanted child if the mother chooses to not abort.

    ESL Round Robin · 2

  • THS the commercialisation of euthanasia

    Mindanao Parliamentary Debate Championship · 2

  • TH as the medical community would strongly support the commercialisation of nutraceuticals

    Mindanao Parliamentary Debate Championship · 2

    Info slide

    Nutraceuticals are products that are derived from food sources purported to provide extra health benefits in addition to the basic nutritional value found in food. Scientific researches have been made to analyse the potential of its ingredients to be used as alternative or in concord with conventional medicine. Most regulatory bodies only classify these as food supplements. The products are labelled with "No Therapeutic Claims." Despite this, nutraceutical companies market its products with claims and testimonies that it can prevent chronic diseases, improve health, delay the aging process, increase life expectancy, or support The structure or function of the body. Examples of available products are Malunggay Herbal Capsules Mangosteen Herbal Capsules, Prebiotics, Raspberry Ketones.

  • Given a way to accurately measure an individual's emotional intelligence (EQ), This House Would only allow individuals with high levels of EQ to be parents.

    Nanjing Online Tournament · 1

    Info slide

    Canceling culture is the phenomenon or practice of publicly rejecting, boycotting, or ending support for particular people or groups (usually public figures) because of their socially or morally unacceptable views or actions. As contrast to canceling culture is context culture, which emphasize on understanding context. This means denouncing mistakes while acknowledging the potential for growth. In short, context culture believes that people can learn from and outgrow their mistakes and should be given the space to do so.

  • Assuming we have reached the point of Singularity, THBT AI should be allowed to run for public office.

    Horizon Cup · Open_Final

    Info slide

    AI singularity is the point in time when AI has begins to exhibit behaviour and intelligence indistinguishable from a human'a and continues to develop independently

  • THW ban the use of placebos in clinical trials involving terminally ill patients

    Horizon Cup · Open_Semi

  • During health crises, THBT local government units should have absolute autonomy on the formulation and implementation of health policies (e.g. quarantine protocols, vaccination rollout).

    Horizon Cup · 1

  • THW prohibit the dispensing of pharmaceuticals over-the-counter.

    Horizon Cup · 1

    Info slide

    Over-the-counter means that a drug with a therapeutic claim can be dispensed without a prescription from a doctor. These drugs include common painkillers (e.g. paracetamol, ibuprofen, mefenamic acid), cough suppressants (dextromethorphan or Rubitussin), and anti-allergenics (loratadine, cetirizine), among others.

  • THR the rise of self-diagnosing mental health conditions

    Horizon Cup · 1

  • THS Dr. Chermann's choice to speak out about Sexton's medical history.

    Sports IV · Silver_Final

    Info slide

    Jonathan Sexton is an Irish rugby union player and captain of Leinster Rugby and Ireland who played for Racing 92 in France between 2013 and 2015. He has scored over 900 points in his international career, making him one of the highest points-scorers in rugby union history. Former Racing 92 Neurologist Dr Chermann has come forward without consulting Sexton to say "I think Johnny Sexton has had around 30 concussions across his entire career. It's true that it's enormous"" ""If Sexton plays on Sunday, it's sad for him. This is what really inspires me: sadness"". Dr Barry O'Driscoll is the former medical adviser to World Rugby who stepped down in 2012 to protest against the governing body's concussion protocols - namely the head injury assessment (HIA) and current six-day return to play protocols. After Dr Chermann's statement, he came forward to again state that there is no scientific basis to the world rugby rules of allowing a player to play 6 days post head injury.

  • THW resign from the hospital

    North Luzon Intervarsity · 1

    Info slide

    You are an overworked doctor in an understaffed public hospital in the pandemic. You have been working in the same hospital since you passed your licensure examination. You are exposed to COVID patients everyday but have a very low hazard pay.

  • THS the "right to try"

    Oldham International League · 1

    Info slide

    The right to try refers to the legal granting to individuals with life-threatening conditions the opportunity to access ('try') experimental treatments - even ones that have yet to pass regulatory approval.

  • THBT animal rights groups should prioritise their campaigns on farmed animals being treated well and killed without excessive pain and suffering, rather than discouraging the use of animal-based products.

    Oldham International League · 4

  • When Possible, THBT researchers should self experiment before conducting human trials.

    Xavier Cup · Open_Octa

  • THW Criminalize Vaccine Misinformation

    Xavier Cup · 1

  • During the pandemic, THBT Medical Workers should have the right to opt out of service

    Xavier Cup · 1

  • THS the use of Vaccine Passports

    Xavier Cup · 1

  • Post-pandemic, THW mandate all companies to have a WFH- option policy

    National Law School Parliamentary Debate · Novice_Final

  • THBT the court should have struck down the provision instead of interpreting it in this manner

    National Law School Parliamentary Debate · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Like many Indian states, Kerala had a legal provision that stated that "no women shall be required or allowed to work in any factory except between the hours of 6 am and 7 pm". In 1994, this was legally challenged on the ground that it amounted to discrimination on the basis of sex, since women were being denied employment opportunities. Given the Indian Constitution's guarantee of equality, some other High Courts have struck down identical provisions as violative of the right to equality. However, the Kerala High Court, while recognizing the right to equality, instead chose to hold that the provision must be construed as "a protection against exploitation of a woman worker by requiring her to work during night hours without her consent". It also held that in a case where the woman herself seeks appointment by waiving the special privilege granted to her under the provision, she could not be denied employment by citing the provision. Thus, the Kerala High Court, instead of striking down the provision, held that it can continue to operate but must be interpreted as: 1) it could not be used to deny women employment if they were willing to work during night hours; 2) At the same time, employers could not legally compel women to work during night hours

  • THBT it is legitimate for students from a lower socioeconomic background to cheat on their job application including cheating in placement tests, lying on their resume, etc.

    National Law School Parliamentary Debate · 2

  • This House Regrets the Stigma Associated with Outsourcing Elder Care

    Oldham Asia Pacific & Atlantic · 4

  • THIS HOUSE PREFERS A WORLD WHERE ALL ACADEMIC RECORDS AND ACHIEVEMENTS OF INDIVIDUALS WERE PRIVATE BETWEEN THE STUDENT AND THEIR ACADEMIC INSTITUTIONS (INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO DEGREES, TRANSCRIPTS, OR ANY EVIDENCE OF SCHOOLS ATTENDED OR MERITS AWARDED, ETC

    Hanoi Debate Open · Open_Quarter

  • THIS HOUSE OPPOSES THE PRIORITIZATION OF HUMAN COMFORT OVER ANIMAL WELFARE (E.G. INDUSTRIAL MEAT AND DAIRY CONSUMPTION, LEATHER, ANIMAL TESTING FOR NON-MEDICALLY ESSENTIAL PURPOSES, ETC).

    Hanoi Debate Open · 3

  • THW disqualify individuals from making important life choices (e.g. having kids, running for political office, etc.) for abusive or neglectful video game play that is not part of core game goals (e.g. shoving your Sims into the cooker to die, starving the deadweight neopet on your roster, etc.)

    Pop Posting Open · Open_Quarter

  • This House, as the individual, would choose to install the device despite the consequences for the cat

    CAMPSDA Debating Championship · Open_Final

    Info slide

    Humans have invented a device that converts cat language into our language and vice versa. The translation is 100% accurate and conveys every emotion and nuance in their tone of voice. This has allowed us to communicate with cats more better and form much closer bonds with them. This device is a one-time solution meaning it is permanent. It has shortened the life-spans of the cats by a margin and made them more susceptible to diseases. Cats with this device also have consent so they have similar rights to human rights as they can communicate with us on an equal level now. You have a kitten. You adopted it when it was born. You were the first individual it saw and it looks at you as a parental figure. It has been recently diagnosed with a terminal disease limiting its lifespan. You are distressed about this and want to make the kittens remaining life an enjoyable experience for it. You feel that getting the device for your cat might potentially help you make its remaining life better for both of you however this means that the life of this cat will be shortened even further beyond its terminal disease. With this in your mind you are tasked with this decision.

  • THR AstraZeneca releasing information and commenting on speculations of side effects of their Covid-19 Vaccines

    Malaysia National Universities Debating Championship · Open_Final

    Info slide

    Recently, Astrazaneca was forced to comment on a rising concerns that their vaccine caused blood clotting in some patients.

  • THR Amnestry's decision to declassify Nalvany as a prisoner of conscience

    Malaysia National Universities Debating Championship · 3

    Info slide

    Amnesty International recently stripped the Russian opposition politician Alexei Navalny of his "prisoner of conscience" status after numerous reports of xenophobic comments that he has made in the past and not renounced came to light. A prisoner of conscience (POC) is anyone imprisoned because of their race, sexual orientation, religion, or political views.

  • There exists a button that, once pressed, would make every human being in the world sterile. THW press the 'button'

    World Changers Camp · Open_Final

  • Assuming the technology to erase half of the humanity exists, THBT humanity should use the technology.

    World Changers Camp · Novice_Semi

  • THW require people to visit a slaughterhouse in order to obtain a license to eat meat

    World Changers Camp · 4

  • THBT billionaires have an obligation to sabotage the development of AI

    World Changers Camp · 2

  • That we should nationalize all proceeds intended for charitable giving

    Loquitur · 1

  • Assuming that we can make testing compulsory, that we should criminalize the spread of irreversible STDs (i.e. HPV, HIV)

    Loquitur · 2

  • Assuming that we have conclusive diagnosis on-hand, That the state should be able to permanently institutionalize sociopaths

    Loquitur · 3

  • That we support giving the WHO power to temporarily confiscate facilities and intellectual property related to the production and research of COVID-19 vaccines.

    Loquitur · Open_Final

  • THS the use of emotional support services

    Kolkata Debates · 1

  • THS the 14-day rule

    Blithchrome Parliamentary Debate · Open_Final

    Info slide

    The 14-day rule is a universally adopted informal policy based on academic field publishing and funding norms (or in some places national law) that prevents scientists from allowing the development of human embryos beyond 14 days. This is the point at which they form a body plan and cells adopt specialised missions. The International Society of Stem Cell Research is currently recommending that this policy be abandoned and such research be moved from prohibited to permissible.

  • Plans are being discussed that would prevent Champions League clubs from buying players from each other, the European Club Association (ECA) president has revealed

    Blithchrome Parliamentary Debate · Novice_Final

  • TH would allocate the majority of public healthcare funds to palliative care, as opposed to treatments for terminal diseases.

    4th Linkbate Debate Championship · 2

    Info slide

    Palliative care is specialized care aimed at optimizing the quality of life and alleviating pain mainly for people with serious, complex illnesses. It is distinctive from other treatments which aims to cure diseases. Palliative care can be used in conjunction with other medical treatments, and is currently underprioritized in terms of research, access, and development.

  • Assuming the technology exists, THW allow individuals to buy and sell the remaining years of their life as opposed to restricting access to the technology completely

    Australs Interschool Debating Championship · Open_Final

  • THW not pursue relationships with non-Reanimationists

    Colgate Open · 3

    Info slide

    You are a teenager who was born into a relatively small ethno-religious group known as the Reanimationists. You can only be born into this group by being born to two Reanimationist parents; you can not convert into it. For this reason, the population of Reanimationists has been declining over the past few centuries. The vast majority of the population has fled their original homeland and now lives in relatively small and widely-dispersed diasporan communities (i.e. a few thousand people). Reanimationist practices include a strong focus on theological and scientific studies, specific clothing and grooming habits, and a strong focus on family and family time.

  • THBT major pharmaceutical companies should cut off supply of its products to governments that don't follow the company's protocol around their distribution and usage.

    Colgate Open · Open_Semi

  • TH, as the medical community, would adopt an optimistic stance towards vaccines that are rolled-out despite having incomplete clinical trial data

    MINT · 3

  • THP a world where human beings naturally expired at age 50

    MINT · Open_Semi

  • In countries with vaccine shortages, THW ban vaccine exports

    IIT BHU PD · 4

  • Under the current pandemic, THBT it is justified for countries to send surplus medical supplies to their key allies over the nations most in need

    IIT BHU PD · 4

  • THBT those who refuse to get vaccinated should be exempt from public/free treatment of COVID-19

    IIT BHU PD · 4

  • TH, as the people of the community, would abandon all research to kill the dragon

    Cameroon Debate Open · Open_Final

    Info slide

    In an alternate world, a dragon once attacked a community and only stopped on the condition of periodic human sacrifices. The community agreed as they had no other way to stop the dragon. Over centuries, society adapted to this and has developed an entire culture around the dragon, including religious beliefs that justify the sacrifices and government bureaucracy that facilitates them and compensates those left behind. The sacrifices are frequent and large enough that almost everyone in the community has lost a loved one during their lifetime. Science has now advanced to the point where a material has been developed that can pierce the dragon's scales, making it possible to launch an attack on the dragon. However, the attack may fail, and the dragon may retaliate against the whole community

  • THO the production of fictional medical series

    Cameroon Debate Open · 4

    Info slide

    Grey's Anatomy, New Amsterdam and Chicago Med, are some of the medical series that have found great following. Many of their storylines use seemingly realistic scenarios, with sometimes outlandish medical solutions.

  • In situations where it is not possible to achieve both aims and the decision is upon the doctor, THBT doctors should prioritise prolonging life over the quality of that life.

    People's Speak Invitational · Open_Final

  • THBT developing countries should disregard intellectual property rights (i.e. patents) on treatments for widespread diseases

    Lasallian Interschool Training · 2

  • THS the rise of AI in mental health therapy

    Lasallian Interschool Training · 2

    Info slide

    Artificial Intelligence (AI) has seen multiple developments in mental health care ranging from computer psychologists, mental health chatbots like ELIZA and coordinated healthcare. It is often used to help patients get a diagnosis through identifying classifiable symptoms or provide treatment through cognitive behavioral therapy protocols

  • THW Ban parents from setting their adopted child up for re-adoption

    Lasallian Interschool Training · 1

    Info slide

    Re-Adoption is a service offered to parents of adopted children who want to offer their adopted child back up for adoption. This is done under various reasons such as: The financial instability of the family to care for the child, The child exhibits violent tendencies that poses a threat to the family or the adopted parents being unable to continue caring for the child. Re-adoption has a 5% failure rate which means that these children are unlikely to be adopted a 3rd time.

  • THBT parents at all times should not lie to their children

    Lasallian Interschool Training · 1

  • THW allow deaf parents to specifically select deaf over hearing embryos in utero

    Yale IV · ESL_Final

    Info slide

    Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) allows parents to evaluate several existing embryos before selecting which to implant via in vitro fertilization (IVF). One of the identifiable traits is genetic deafness.

  • THBT the use of online applications for treating mental health issues (anxiety, depression) has done more harm than good

    SLIDE UP: Southern Luzon Inter High School Debate Encounter XII · 4

  • THP a world where crystals indicating mental health (not momentary mood) existed for every human being

    LUMS IV · 3

    Info slide

    In the game 'the Sims', a glowing crystal hovers above each Sim's head and indicates its health and wellbeing. The crystal is green when the Sim is perfectly healthy, but shifts to yellow, orange, and even red as the Sim's physical condition deteriorates. These crystals are not tangible, but their image is totally visible to everyone.

  • THW allow children to sue their parents for developmental trauma

    Heritage Parliamentary Debate · 1

    Info slide

    Developmental trauma describes mental (and sometimes, physical) damages that occur in their own homes during the early developmental stages of one's life (infancy, child age, and teenage years)

  • THP the view that dying is a medical process as opposed to a spiritual process

    Heritage Parliamentary Debate · Open_Final

  • This House would only allow lawyers to reject work in areas in which they practice based on the prospects of success as opposed to the client's identity

    Beihang Winter Debate Open · 3

  • Upon the condition that essential medical workers and the most vulnerable have been vaccinated, This House believes that the WHO should compel its rich members to donate their vaccines to COVAX for fair and equitable distribution to low middle-income and lowest income countries.

    Beihang Winter Debate Open · 5

  • Assuming access for all, THW legalize cognitive gene enhancement.

    Bicol Intervarsity · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Cognitive gene enhancement refers to interventions made to improve memory, attention, concentration, information processing such as critical thinking and decision making, and other intellectual traits. These interventions are done through different genetic editing techniques that change the coding sequence of specific genes until the desired sequence is attained.

  • THR the prevalence of prenatal testing for genetic disorders (i.e. chromosomal abnormalities like down syndrome)

    Bicol Intervarsity · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Prenatal testing is a common procedure done to test a child's overall health. One type of prenatal test screens a baby's risk for chromosomal abnormalities (i.e. genetic conditions such as Down Syndrome, Tay-Sachs syndrome, etc.). The blood tests used to screen these chromosomal abnormalities simply assess risk and are not always accurate.

  • TH, as the Jewish surgeon, would refuse to operate on the patient.

    Bicol Intervarsity · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    A Jewish surgeon was assigned to operate on a 36 year old man with brain tumor. The patient was already anaesthetized, when the doctor saw that the patient had a Swastika (Nazi symbol) tattoo on his left shoulder.

  • This house believes that Batman should abandon his no-killing rule

    Justice Tarkunde PD · Novice_Final

  • THS medical conscription during pandemics

    Christ University Parliamentary Debate · 2

  • TH celebrates AI powered social robots in senior health care

    Bulacan High School Public Debate Championship · Open_Semi

  • THBT obesity should be treated as a public health concern instead of a personal one.

    Bulacan High School Public Debate Championship · Open_Semi

  • THW deny organ transplants for patients living an unhealthy lifestyle

    Bulacan High School Public Debate Championship · Open_Semi

  • Given these biases, THW prohibit the use of AI in social institutions (e.g. universities, government, corporations etc.)

    Bulacan High School Public Debate Championship · 4

    Info slide

    AI systems learn to make decisions based on training data, which can include biased human decisions or reflect historical or social inequities, even if sensitive variables such as gender, race, or sexual orientation are removed. These biases can creep into AI's algorithms in several ways. (Example, Amazon stopped using a hiring algorithm after finding it favored applicants based on words like "executed" or "captured" that were more commonly found on men's resumes

  • Assuming the technology existed and it was safe, THW allow people to erase certain memories.

    HK WSDC · Novice_Final

  • This House Regrets the notion of science being apolitical

    Ziauddin University Debating Championship · Open_Semi

  • TH (as the conscience of an 18 year old) would take the potion

    3rd NPD UPES · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    There is a potion which can stop you from falling in love

  • THR modern medicine's prioritisation of longevity over quality of life (e.g. extending lifespan vs. palliative care)

    LSE Open · 1

  • THBT, in a context where they would remain illegal in the United States and Europe, Latin American countries should legalise all drugs.

    Pan American Queer Open · 1

  • Assuming you had the capability to do so, this house, as a benevolent actor, would destroy the Akashic Records.

    Pan American Queer Open · 3

    Info slide

    The Akashic Records refer to a stone tablet which contains the details of all human events, thoughts, words, emotions, and intent ever to have occurred in the past, present, or future.

  • THBT the WHO should outwardly and definitively condemn the Sri Lankan government's policy of compulsory cremation in Sri Lanka.

    Pan American Queer Open · Open_PreFinal

    Info slide

    In 2020, Sri Lanka made cremation mandatory for the remains of people who were infected with/died of COVID-19. This enabled cremation against the wishes of the family, notwithstanding any cultural practices. This was widely reported to be disproportionately applied to Muslim communities. WHO (and many other healthcare bodies) guidelines state that there is little to no evidence suggesting the necessity of cremation for those who died of COVID-19, and that cultural practices should be respected. Since early in the pandemic, the WHO has been working closely with the Sri Lankan government to promote COVID-19 safety, disseminating information on controlling the spread, and helping to secure resources.

  • TH, as adopting parents, would not tell their kids they're adopted when it is reasonably possible to conceal that information

    Trinity IV · 1

  • THW ban research into the genetic connection between identity groups (e.g. ethnicity, gender) and attributes (e.g. intelligence, compassion)

    Trinity IV · 5

  • THBT the medical community should invest in anti-aging research on the same scale as other top priorities, including cancer and heart disease research

    Bates Quimbly Pro Am · Open_Semi

  • THBT we should prioritise policies that seek to help people currently alive over those that seek to protect future generations

    Bates Quimbly Pro Am · ESL_Final

  • In a world where self driving cars exist, THP, that in cases of accidents when some damage is bound to occur, self driving cars be programmed to outsource the decision to the human driver (the car would not make a mathematical harm calculus), over picking the outcome that causes the least numerical human harm.

    DTU PD 2021 · 2

  • THW mandate pharmaceutical corporations to reveal the cost involved in research and development

    DTU PD 2021 · 4

  • TH, as a developing country, would implement BioBonds to fund medical research

    Wolce Pro Ams · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Bio Bonds are a new tool of financing medical research used to harness billions in institutional capital. The bio bond market is traded privately with the backing of a limited guarantee from the government. Bio Bonds are currently being looked into as a way to fund niche fields of medical research like curing blindness.

  • THBT it would be preferable for Beth had her father agreed to financially support her and her mom, preventing the accident

    Sir Vishahara Memorial Parliamentary Debate · 3

    Info slide

    Beth Harmon was an only daughter to a single mom, they were living on their own in a caravan. When Beth was 9, her father declined to financially support her and her mom. As a result, her mom intentionally crashed her car with Beth and her in it. While Beth survived unharmed, her mom died. She then moved to the orphanage, where she discoverd her passion and gift for playing chess having learned from the orphanage janitor. She lived on to pursue a competitive international chess career.

  • Thbt all existing HeLa cells should be destroyed

    Uhuru Worlds · 5a

  • THS the use of human challenge trials (HCTs) in the development of COVID-19 vaccines.

    Debatable Open · 3

    Info slide

    HCTs are trials that intentionally introduce an infectious disease organism to participants. In effect, expediting the usual vaccine development process, which normally requires a large group of people to be exposed to the disease naturally and may take over several years or decades to be completed. The demand for a COVID-19 vaccine has prompted vaccine developers to consider HCTs despite the lack of rescue treatments should any participant get sick.

  • THW only allow the media and campaigning organisations to depict or publish information about the deceased in a tragedy with the explicit permission of the family.

    Doxbridge Worlds · Open_Quad

  • THBT tax avoidance on the grounds of conscientious objection is legitimate

    Sunyani Pro Am · 1

    Info slide

    A conscientious objector is an "individual who has refused to perform military service" on the grounds of freedom of thought, conscience, or religion. It is seen as legitimate in most western liberal democracies to refuse military service on this basis.

  • Assuming the options are limited to debt foregiveness or zero interest loans, THW choose debt forgiveness

    Xtension IV · Open_Semi

    Info slide

    Due to COVID-19, there has been a global economic slowdown hitting developing countries most due to the slump in demand for commodities which their economies are reliant on. As such, there has began a campaign for the first world to come to their aid.

  • TH rejects the medical orthodoxy that resource optimisation should be determined by who lives and who dies

    Xtension IV · 3

    Info slide

    1. The three wise men protocol refers to a scenario where in the event that public medical utilities are stretched thin, a panel of senior consultants in each hospital or health facility are empowered with the task of determining who gets care and to what extent resources are to be spent on a patient. 2. Computer algorithms have recently been developed that can accurately predict when terminally ill patients are likely to die. It has been proposed that such software be used to determine scarce hospital resource allocation.

  • This House believes that developed states that receive medical professionals emigrating from developing countries should pay compensation to the government of the professionals' country of origin

    WSDC 2021 · Octofinals (impromptu) · World Schools Debating Championships

2020 (8 motions)

  • R1 - THW allow medical professionals to give medicine to underage children irrespective of the children's and their parent's consent

    Downpour Open '20 · 1

  • Assuming Personal Protective Equipment is sufficiently available, THBT medical workers during a pandemic should have the right to opt out of service.

    Asia Queer Open · 2

  • THP a world where the pill exists

    Berlin Online IV · 2

    Info slide

    A pill has recently been invented which can fully emotionally distances the individual taking it from a person of their choosing. The pill is free and easily available to everyone in the world, and only works when voluntarily taken. The pill is safe and irreversible.

  • THR the narrative that being a nurse is a calling rather than a job

    Deree Invitational LIX · 2

  • This House Believes That scientific literature should be free

    Central European Cyberspace Open · 5

  • This House Would ban the breeding of wild animals for petting programs at zoos

    VITDT Round Robin 2020 · 1

    Info slide

    Petting zoos are zoos where patrons are allowed to touch and interact with wild animals, such as tigers. Examples of such facilities iclude Doc Antie's Myrtle Beach Safari, and Dolphin Petting at Sea World. Petting facilities often breed animals to ensure that there is a constant supply of animals to pet.

  • Assuming you lived a middle class life, THW choose to upload their consciousness to this technology.

    Eastern Online IV · 4

    Info slide

    A technology has been created that allows individuals to upload their consciousness to an online reality after their death. The virtual afterlife is an idyllic version of reality with different levels of luxury depending on which tier you paid for. Uploaded people can contact people in the real world, feel any and all sensations, and buy luxury items and amenities with weath they made before their deaths or money given to them from living donors (friends, family, etc). There exists no other similar technology: a person must choose between this technology or a natural death.

  • TH, as Dr. Anthony Fauci, would publicly and actively call out Trump whenever he gives false medical advice to the general public.

    Axiom Debate Open 2020 · Novice_Final

    Info slide

    Dr. Anthony Fauci is an American physician and immunologist who has served as the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) since 1984. Since January 2020, he has been one of the lead members of the Trump Administration's White House Coronavirus Task Force addressing the 2019–20 coronavirus pandemic in the United States. Fauci is widely seen to be one of the most trusted medical figures in the country.

More topic collections

Or start from the full motion bank and the Worlds motions archive.

Motions are free. Judged rounds are the product.

Our students debate motions like these every week in full judged rounds, with oral adjudication and written feedback after every one.

Book a Consultation