Motion Bank · By year
Debate motions from 2021
2,432 motions were set at 231 tournaments during 2021, verbatim from public tab records. The 200below come from that season's largest tournaments. They include 28 motions from that year's World Schools Debating Championships. To reach the other 2,232, or to search by keyword and topic, use the explorer filtered to 2021.
UADC 2021 (48 motions)
This house believes that it is a legitimate tactic for activists to launch campaigns of personal attacks/insults at the family members of corrupt politicians
EFL_Final
This house supports the strategy of activists publicly shaming those who do not actively denounce problematic individuals
EFL_Final
This house prefers a narrative of collective blame for ethnic divides within a community, rather than the blame being placed exclusively on institutions or externalities
EFL_Final
This house prefers a world where Islam has its own central authority (e.g. The Pope or the Magisterium in Catholicism)
EFL_Semi
This house believes that religious organisations should excommunicate members who commit serious crimes against society
EFL_Semi
This house, as the Catholic Church, would abolish the papal conclave and select its succeeding Popes through an election among all its members (i.e. its religious followers)
EFL_Semi
Info slide
A papal conclave is convened when the College of Cardinals needs to appoint the successor of The Pope. The College of Cardinals is appointed by the current Pope and usually consists of ordained bishops.
This house regrets the rise of shows/films which involve mental suffering and self-harm (e.g. Bojack Horseman, Black Swan, 13 Reasons Why)
EFL_Quarter
This house, as WWE, would induct Chris Benoit in the WWE Hall of Fame
EFL_Quarter
Info slide
The late Chris Benoit was a former professional wrestler who worked for the WWE. During his career, Chris Benoit held 22 championships between the industry's top promotions and won the World Heavyweight Championship in the main event of Wrestlemania XX, the largest wrestling show at the time. In June 2007, Chris Benoit murdered his wife, his son, and himself. A medical report of Chris Benoit's brain revealed he had suffered from depression and chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE). It was suggested that these resulted from numerous concussions Chris Benoit had sustained by performing moves that the WWE permitted him to do. Since then, WWE has removed, censored, and banned all mentions of Chris Benoit from their networks and media.
This house believes that contemporary black film makers should actively create films which embrace blaxploitation
EFL_Quarter
Info slide
Blaxploitation movies refer to groups of films that feature black actors in lead roles and center around African diasporas overcoming oppressive, antagonistic and generally white authority figures aided by lackeys selling out the community for their personal gain. The term "blaxploitation" was coined by parts of the community in the early 70s as criticism for the images of African Americans depicted in the genre, and the typically white filmmakers at the helm of production. Prominent films of this genre range from "Watermelon Man" and "Blacula" from the 1970s to more recent films like "Django Unchained" and "BlacKkKlansman" from the 2000s which involve messages of empowerment. The genre became less popular in the 80s after it received criticisms for its "unpolished nature" and controversial themes heavily involving drugs and violence but has since then made a more popular comeback.
This house prefers a world where religions actively preach the concept of the Divine Gift
Open_Final
Info slide
For the purpose of this debate, the concept of Divine Gift is the concept wherein God bestows a believer with faith and or sense of religiosity. Non believers are seen as people who were simply not bestowed with this gift, rather than individuals who actively or passively strayed from faith.
This house believes that moderate Muslims should refrain from attempting to reclaim the term jihad in the aftermath of terrorist attacks
Open_Final
Info slide
The literal meaning of Jihad is struggle or effort. Muslims use the word Jihad to describe three different kinds of struggle namely a believer's internal struggle to live out the Muslim faith as well as possible, the struggle to live as a good Muslim society and the struggle to defend Islam, with force if necessary. The term has been more infamously and commonly associated with Islamist fundamentalists, to refer to the instances of violent resistance and militaristic pursuits to defend the faith.
This house believes that religious leaders should abandon the narrative that difficulties in life are "tests of God"
Open_Final
Info slide
The "tests of God" refers to the belief that hardships and difficulties in life only exist to test one's spiritual and emotional strength
This house supports the narrative that current generations have a duty to protect the rights of future generations who do not exist yet
Open_Semi
This house opposes fallen soldiers believing their deaths would be meaningful
Open_Semi
This house prefers a world where individuals live in recognition of their moral flaws as opposed to a convenient morality
Open_Semi
Info slide
"Convenient Morality" refers to rationalising your actions and justifying decisions to retroactively fit into your code of beliefs, i.e., an individual adapting their beliefs and morals to the actions as opposed to accepting that certain actions transgress your chosen set of morals.
This house supports Gulf States intervening in Ethiopia
Open_Quarter
Info slide
Gulf States refer to Bahrain, Kuwait, Iraq, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates. Tigray is Ethiopia's northernmost region. Bordering Eritrea, it is home to most of the country's estimated 7 million ethnic Tigrayans. In November 2020, the regional government, controlled by the Tigray People's Liberation Front, launched a full-scale siege of a key Ethiopian military base. Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed ordered a federal offensive against the region, setting off a conflict which has killed thousands of people - many of whom allegedly died as a result of indiscriminate shelling of cities in Tigray by Ethiopian forces, and has seen nearly 60,000 people fleeing to Sudan.
This house believes that the Naftali Bennet administration is in the best interest of the Middle East
Open_Quarter
Info slide
Benjamin Netanyahu was ousted from office by a coalition of rivals earlier this year, ending his 12-year run in power. Israel's new prime minister, Naftali Bennett, was sworn in after a vote of confidence with the narrow margin of 60 votes to 59. Bennett, the far right leader of Yamina party, will be prime minister until September 2023 as part of a power-sharing deal. He will then hand power over to Yair Lapid, head of the centrist Yesh Atid party, for a further two years. The administration is a mix of politicians from the left (Labor), the centre (Lapid), hardline Jewish religious nationalists, and a small Arab Islamist party
As a prominent Pro-Palestine journalist in the west covering the conflicts in Israel-Palestine, this house would choose not to focus on Hamas' role in the escalation of the conflict
Open_Quarter
TH would choose to be born in Fantasia Over Earth
Open_Octa
Info slide
Fantasia is a world where everyone is equally happy, but nobody can become more happy or sad during their lifetime. On Earth, people are much happier or much sadder than others, but have the ability to become more happy or sad during their lifetime
This house welcomes research that seeks to transfer human consciousness into simulations, computers, and artificial intelligence
Open_Octa
TH, as the parent, would not give their consent
Open_Octa
Info slide
The world is in ruin and has long been corrupted. You are the single parent of a young child who would be the only cure for a virus threatening to infect mankind with a rabid disease. Your child must be killed in order for the cure to be extracted and save the human race. The procedure requires your consent.
This house would prohibit provincial and local governments from offering tax credits and other incentives to attract large companies to open business in their regions
Open_PDO
This house prefers individuals seeking maximum material gain as opposed to meaning / fulfilment from their work
Open_PDO
This House regrets China's focus on "Common Prosperity"
Open_PDO
Info slide
The term "Common prosperity" was first mentioned in the 1950s by Mao Zedong, founding leader of what was then an impoverished country. It was not used as frequently under Deng Xiaoping, who shifted the focus to developing an economy that would allow "some people to get rich first." Xi Jin Ping made it a central part of his 2017 speech at the party congress to mark the start of his second term, and the messaging really took off in 2021. The slogan has since been adopted by state agencies and private companies as a way to signal their allegiance to this Communist Party priority. The push for common prosperity has encompassed policies ranging from curbing tax evasion and limits on the hours that tech sector employees can work to bans on for-profit tutoring in core school subjects and strict limits on the time minors can spend playing video games.
This House, as the parents, would not have children
8
Info slide
For the purpose of this debate you are a couple in their late 30s. You have always wanted to have children but have failed to conceive. You find out you can have a child who will be incredibly successful and happy in life due to your parenting; however upon reaching adulthood they would abandon you. This is the only child that you can have.
In a state with failing adoption homes/numbers This House would put a moratorium on IVF clinics
8
As a parent from a minority community, this house would teach their children to pursue a mediocre but satisfactorily happy life over a life which involves a constant pursuit of excellence and the extraordinary
8
This House believes that the CPTPP should accept China's application
7
Info slide
The CPTPP (Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership) is a free trade agreement signed in 2018 between 11 countries: Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore, and Vietnam. The treaty was originally envisioned by the US as an economic bloc to counterbalance China's growing power but the US pulled out in 2017. The CPTPP aims to create an integrated economic area by eliminating/reducing tariffs, liberalizing trade, opening each other's markets to foreign investment, etc. It has strict conditions for joining such as high liberalization requirements in service trade, high standards for intellectual property protections, high labor and environmental standards. Recently, both China and Taiwan have filed an application to join the CPTPP
This House believes that it is in the interests of India to offically recognise the Taliban regime of Afghanistan
7
This House regrets the signing of the AUKUS pact
7
Info slide
Recently the AUKUS pact was announced between the US, the UK and Australia which will see the US and UK send strategic and technical teams to Australia to help the country procure nuclear-powered submarines. It also meant that the Australian government cancelled a multi-billion contract for non-nuclear submarines with a French manufacturer.
This House regrets progressives abandoning political moralism
6
Info slide
For the purposes of this debate, political moralism refers to the philosophy that moral standards (e.g. beliefs and virtues) should predominantly be used when judging political groups.
This House blieves that environmentalists should put a monetary value on environmental functions
6
Info slide
An ecosystem function is the capacity of natural processes and components to provide goods and services that satisfy human needs, either directly or indirectly (e.g., forests ,wetlands, coastlines etc.)
This house, as pride event organizers, would actively work with corporations that adopt rainbow capitalism
6
Info slide
Rainbow capitalism is the targeted incorporation of the LGBTQ+ movement to capitalism, consumerism, and the market economy by corporations. Examples include, but are not limited to, LGBT-related products, designs, brands, and sponsorships
This House opposes the norm that individuals should "see the best in others"
5
This House would actively discourage home-ownership
5
This House regrets the culture of fearing death
5
This House regrets the rise of digital currencies
4
Info slide
For the purpose of this debate, digital currencies refer to a virtual format of a fiat currency for a particular nation or region. It is an electronic record or digital token of the official currency and is issued and regulated by its monetary authority, e.g., Digital Yuan in China and Digital Rupee in India.
Assuming technology exists, this house would operationalize the entire Criminal Justice System (e.g. Judges, Juries etc.) using Artificial Intelligence
4
This house would require social media users to verify their identities before creating an account (e.g. provide proof of identity and documentation)
4
This House Would ban collateralised loan obligations
3
Info slide
A collateralized loan obligation (CLO) is a single security backed by a pool of debt. Collateralized loan obligations (CLO) are often backed by corporate loans with low credit ratings or loans taken out by private equity firms to conduct leveraged buyouts.With a CLO, the investor receives scheduled debt payments from the underlying loans, assuming most of the risk in the event that borrowers default. In exchange for taking on the default risk, the investor is offered the potential for higher-than-average returns
This House would ban private sector management of pension funds
3
Info slide
A pension fund, also known as a superannuation fund in some countries, is any plan, fund, or scheme which provides retirement income. A public pension fund is one that is regulated under public sector law while a private pension fund is regulated under private sector law.
This house regrets western institutions' push for market liberalisation
3
This house believes that feminist movements in developing nations should deprioritise the strategy of advocating for carceral feminism
2
Info slide
Carceral feminism is the advocacy for enhancing and increasing prison sentences that deal with feminist and gender issues. It is the belief that harsher and longer prison sentences will help work towards solving these issues
This Hous regrets the glorification of women's resilience
2
Assuming the technology exists, this house would allow minority women of colour, with no affinity to their gender and race, to alter their identity to that of the majority gender and race
2
This house regrets the increasing trend of universities in Asia partnering with global western universities (e.g. Yale-Nus, MIT-SUTD)
1
This house believes that universities should not accept research funding and scholarships from corrupted / problematic organizations and donors
1
This house believes that universities should primarily consider teaching ability and performance rather than research outputs when awarding tenure and allocating academic funding
1
PIDC 2021 (42 motions)
THP a hollowed Philippine state
Open_Final
Info slide
A hollowed state has a governance system where the state primarily and predominantly contracts all traditional public services and goods to third party organizations (e.g. corporations, non-profit organizations, NGOs, aid agencies, etc.). The government, both national and local, in a hollowed state develops the political agenda of their state and facilitates a network of participating third parties but has a reduced control and supervision over projects handled by third parties. These third parties bid for government projects and become accountable for the end-to-end management and completion of these projects.
THBT the Makabayan Bloc should actively condemn and distance themselves from the Communist Party of the Philippines - New People's Army (CPP-NPA)
Open_Final
Info slide
The Makabayan Bloc is a coalition of leftist Philippine political parties in the House of Representatives of the Philippines. The political parties represent peasants, workers, women, teachers, youth, migrants, and indigenous peoples (e.g. Bayan Muna, ACT Teachers, Kabataan). They are also allied with militant civil society organizations like Anakbayan, Kilusang Mayo Uno, and Piston.
TH, as the Philippine opposition, would actively capitalize on PNoy's legacy in the 2022 elections
Open_Final
THBT local governments should prioritize predictive analytics as opposed to a participatory approach when crafting comprehensive development plans
Novice_Final
Info slide
Predictive analytics is a branch of advanced analytics used to make predictions about unknown future events. Predictive analytics uses many techniques including data mining, statistical modeling, and machine learning to analyze current data to make predictions about the future. Participatory approach in development primarily involves the community or stakeholders in the discussions and decision making process of policies that affect them.
TH, as a developing country, will cap skills based emigration
Novice_Final
THBT Western Liberal Democracies should place an additional tax on companies wherein a majority of the workforce is on a work from home (WFH) basis
Novice_Final
THR the splintering of the Internet
Open_Semi
Info slide
The "splintering of the internet" refers to the trend in which regulations and barriers that separate how different parts of the world use the internet are becoming more widely adopted. Examples of this include China's Great Firewall, Australia's unique media ownership regulations, the EU's General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR), and Russia's Sovereign Internet Law.
THS the creation of Facebook Metaverse
Open_Semi
Info slide
Mark Zuckerberg recently announced their ambition to transform Facebook into a metaverse that seeks to actively replace social, workplace, and entertainment spaces. The metaverse uses augmented reality technology to create a virtual environment where users can be present with other users in digital spaces. These users are seemingly immersed in these spaces rather than just looking at them. No sole company can create and run a metaverse. Its success would rely on the cooperation and immutable record-keeping among Facebook and other companies.
THW require all social media companies (e.g. Google, Apple, Facebook, WhatsApp, etc.) to leave a backdoor in their users' encrypted data such that the company could retrieve the data under a court order
Open_Semi
THR the trend of the posthumous completion and/or release of deceased artists' works (e.g. films, albums, etc.)
Novice_Semi
THR the emphasis placed on artists' mental disorders (e.g. depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia) in the celebration of their work
Novice_Semi
THBT award giving bodies have no place in art
Novice_Semi
THS a universal basic income as a tool for poverty alleviation
Open_Quarter
THBT the microfinance industry has done more harm than good
Open_Quarter
Info slide
The microfinance industry is the sub-sector of financial services uniquely designed to target small businesses and the poor. Common features of microfinance organizations include, but are not limited to, not requiring collateral, hedging risk with group liability, and charging higher interest rates to its users when compared to traditional banking services.
THBT the US should employ further quantitative easing as opposed to increased spending on stimulus and relief packages to recover from the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic
Open_Quarter
Info slide
For the purposes of this debate, stimulus and relief packages pertain to direct cash transfers to beneficiaries, deferment of loan repayment requirements, and other government covered expenditures unique to the pandemic (e.g testing kits, tax credit to companies granting sick leaves to employees, etc). Quantitative easing is a monetary policy wherein the central bank purchases long-term securities to lower interest rates in the short to medium term.
THBT the feminist movement should abandon the narrative that "gender does not matter" in the fight for equality
Open_Octa
TH, as a progressive working woman in a developed country, would not outsource domestic work
Open_Octa
THR reclamation efforts of the feminist movement towards practices rooted in patriarchy (e.g. being a housewife, wearing make-up or heels, opting for cosmetic surgery)
Open_Octa
THBT the African Union should adopt a single currency
Open_PDO
THBT ASEAN should make Myanmar's membership contingent on active restoration efforts for its democratic institutions and systems
Open_PDO
THBT the Commonwealth of Nations has done more harm than good to developing countries.
Open_PDO
Info slide
The Commonwealth of Nations, commonly referred to simply as the Commonwealth, is a political association composed of former British colonies (e.g. Canada, Malaysia, India, Kenya). Its origins were to recognize these countries as members of the British empire, but it has transitioned to an organization meant to promote justice & human rights, democracy, and economic opportunities for members.
THR the premium placed on "hiya" as a moral virtue
7
Info slide
The Filipino concept of hiya manifests into two interrelated definitions: (1) the hiya that is suffered as shame or embarrassment and (2) the hiya that is an active and sacrificial self-control of one's individual wants for the sake of other people.
TH, as a working-class Filipino abroad in the technology industry, would come home and work in the Philippine technology sector (e.g. research and development, fintech, edtech, and e-commerce)
7
THR the emphasis placed on ilustrados (e.g. Jose Rizal, Juan Luna, Felix Hidalgo) in Philippine History
7
THR the commercialisation of self care
6
THP a user-centric model of compensation as opposed to a pro-rata model of compensation within music streaming services
6
Info slide
A pro-rata model of compensation divides the total pool of revenue the platform earns to artists and their respective companies on the basis of their share of all listeners' plays. Under this model, even if you personally do not listen to popular artists, your money is still going to them. A user-centric model of compensation detects what genres and types of artists a specific user listens to, and distributes money generated from them based only on this. This means that money from a person who listens predominantly to hiphop will go towards hiphop artists, and not necessarily to the most popular artists with the largest share of streams at the moment.
THR the glorification of "ride or die" relationships
6
Info slide
Ride or die is a colloquial expression of extreme loyalty to someone. It is a slang derived from the phrase "ride till the end or die trying." It pertains to a kind relationship where you stand by each other through any problem. Another definition is when one is willing to do anything for someone they love or highly appreciate in their life. This includes romantic, friendly, and familial relationships.
THW legalise assisted suicide
5
THP pedophilia to be framed as a psychiatric disorder as opposed to being purely criminal in public discourse
5
THR the rise of care bots
5
Info slide
Care bots are an emerging breed of robotics catered to the specialized care of the elderly and individuals who face cognitive or social decline. These robots perform the work done by human caregivers including setting medicine reminders, guiding individuals to the bathroom, and contacting loved ones in the case of an emergency.
THR the glorification of PM Justin Trudeau
4
THBT the Nobel Committee should revoke Abiy Ahmed's Nobel prize
4
THO Joe Biden's decision to withdraw American troops from Afghanistan
4
THBT religious organizations should actively endorse candidates in the 2022 Philippine national elections
3
TH, as the Roman Catholic Church, supports its members building a personal relationship with God even at the expense of practicing religious traditions (e.g. engaging in the sacraments, spiritual direction, etc.)
3
THBT religion is incompatible with social development
3
THBT developing countries should adopt Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) regulations
2
Info slide
Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) is a policy approach under which producers are required to be responsible for the treatment and disposal of their post-consumer products both financially and physically.
THBT environmental movements should make campaigning for fossil fuel divestment their primary strategy against climate change
2
Info slide
The campaign for fossil fuel divestment refers to environmental movements asking institutions, corporations, and investors to move their money out of oil, coal, and gas companies for both moral and financial reason
THW impose carbon taxes on individuals
2
THR the premium placed on post-graduate degrees (e.g. MBA, PhD, JD, etc.)
1
THS removing standardized tests as a basis for academic promotions and admissions
1
THR the commercialisation of college admissions coaching
1
Info slide
College admissions coaching can refer to private coaches and CET (College Entrance Tests) review centers. Private coaches are employed by families and offer personalized advice to help the students in selecting and applying for colleges. They can also help guide in students' decision-making on extracurricular activities to join, curriculum/subjects to take, and college essay topics, among others. CET review centers also offer scholarship slots to deserving students for the review classes.
DTU PD 2021 (35 motions)
TH, as new immigrants, Would prioritise the preservation of their traditional culture in the household over assimilating to the new culture
Novice_Semi
THP expositional storytelling in fiction, as opposed to interpretive
Open_Final
Info slide
Expositional storytelling is a method used in fiction, where the author explicitly states and portrays the meaning behind plot events and character motivations without leaving too much room for interpretation. By contrast, interpretative storytelling is when the author decides to show or write events or characters by codifying them behind a symbol or leaving them ambiguous to how the audience may interpret them.
THW allow companies to buy the rights to economicallly failing cities
Novice_Final
Assuming free consent was given, THW permits people to participate in the Octopus Game.
Open_Semi
Info slide
In the Octopus Game, players participate in a series of games in pursuit of winning a massive pool of money, that would make them and all their descendants financially independent. If they lose a game, they die.
TH as the US would ease the sanctions imposed on Venezuela
Open_Quarter
THBT public universities should consider the political beliefs of professors in hiring and tenure decisions in order to ensure ideological representation.
5
THBT copyright has done more harm than good for artists.
4
THBT feminist groups should refrain from claiming that women who oppose feminism are operating under false consciousness.
3
Info slide
False consciousness refers a way of thinking that prevents a person from perceiving the true nature of their social or economic situation.
In emerging democracies, THW cap the maximum number of seats in a parliament that a political party can get.
2
THBT Indian players opting to primarily play in the IPL has done more harm than good for the Indian nation cricketing team.
1
Info slide
The Indian Premier League (IPL) is a professional Twenty20 cricket league, contested by ten teams based out of ten Indian cities. The league was founded by the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) in 2007. It is usually held between March and May of every year. A team can acquire players through any of the three ways: the annual player auction, trading players with other teams during the trading windows, and signing replacements for unavailable players. Players sign up for the auction and also set their base price, and are bought by the franchise that bids the highest for them. Recently there has been a trend of more players within India opting to play in the IPL than in the international circuit, which is typically how most international players gather experience for tournaments such as the World Cup or Champions' Trophy.
THS higher than usual taxes on non-essential businesses (Netflix, Zoom) that made significant profits due to the pandemic
1
THBT it is morally justified for individuals to evade inheritance tax
1
THBT the regulation of overconsumption of common shared resources is justified
1
Info slide
Common shared resources are resources everyone has equal access to, for example, roads. Overconsumption of shared common resources often has negative outcomes, for example – taking numerous flights in a given period, using a car everyday, overgrazing on common fields.
In a world where self driving cars exist, THP, that in cases of accidents when some damage is bound to occur, self driving cars be programmed to outsource the decision to the human driver (the car would not make a mathematical harm calculus), over picking the outcome that causes the least numerical human harm.
2
THW allow the "Human Sims" game
2
Info slide
The Sims is a life-simulation video game where you control all the activities of a virtual character. There now exists a technology that allows real humans to opt into this game as characters. For the duration of the game, these "Human-Sims" will be under the control of another person. Once the game ends, the Human-Sims will have no memory of this experience. They will also be financially rewarded.
THW as the working class, supports creating digital clones of themselves
2
Info slide
There is a technology that allows people to create digital sentient clones of themselves. These clones can perform your daily chores (assignments, office work, etc). The clone will be stored in an egg-shaped device, and will have a mind of its own. A corporation mass produces this technology aimed at the working class to make it easily available for them.
TH (as the Radical Left) supports Liberation Theology
3
Info slide
Liberation theology was a late 20th-century Roman Catholic movement arising in Latin America. The Liberationists said the church should act to bring about social change, and should ally itself with the working class to do so. Some radical priests became involved in politics and trade unions; others even aligned themselves with violent revolutionary movements.
THR de-platformation of parler
3
Info slide
Parler is an American alt-tech microblogging and social networking service. Parler has a significant user base of Donald Trump supporters, conservatives, conspiracy theorists, and right-wing individuals. Posts on the service often contain far-right content, and conspiracy theories such as QAnon. Journalists have described Parler as an alternative to Twitter, and users include those banned from mainstream social networks or opposing their moderation policies
THR the rise of political language to legitimise personal emotions. [E.g. Care labour being the explanation for anxiety of womxn vs emotional drain you feel for your work as an individual]
3
THW limit corporate funding of scientific research
4
THW mandate pharmaceutical corporations to reveal the cost involved in research and development
4
TH, as the LGBTQIA+ movement, would reject legalisation as an avenue of emancipation
5
THBT capitalism is incompatible with LGBTQIA+ justice
5
THBT complete gender emancipation requires the end of family as a dominant social construct
5
In the wake of the economic frustration brought by Covid-19 pandemic, THBT the African states should not have discontinued the use of CFA franc.
Open_Octa
Info slide
The CFA franc encompassed 14 West and Central African nations, including Niger, Cameroon, Mali and Côte d'Ivoire. The currency was pegged at a fixed rate against the euro, and compelled participating African countries to deposit 50% of their foreign exchange reserves with the French treasury. This in turn guaranteed payments into euros even if the CFA member state could not meet import payments. While an important source of financial stability, the CFA franc has long been politically sensitive owing to the power it exerts over countries which have now been independent from France for over half a century, and has recently come to an end as of July 2020.
THO Vaccine Nationalism
Open_Octa
Info slide
Vaccine nationalism is a phenomena where individual nation states secure doses of vaccines for their own citizens or residents and prioritise the local markets before making the vaccine available to global markets. This is done via pre-purchase agreements between a government and a vaccine manufacturer.
THBT India should heavily militarise ANI
Open_Octa
Info slide
Andaman and Nicobar islands(ANI) are Island territories of Republic of India situated in Bay of Bengal. The armed forces of India has a moderate presence in the archipelago with few naval and airforce bases. Since 1980 there have been calls by civil society members and members of armed forces to increase military presence in the archipelago to deter Chinese naval presence near the Indian territorial waters. This policy includes strategies like increasing the number of ports, airports, missile batteries and increased cooperation with US, Australian and Japanese Navies to create a submerged sonar system which runs from the northernmost to southernmost island which may potentially detect presence of Chinese submarines etc
THBT the point system should provide positive points if the overall impact of actions are good (including any collateral damage), even if their motivations are corrupt.
Open_Quarter
Info slide
The Afterlife is divided into The Good Place and The Bad Place. You go to the Good Place if you have a positive point total of actions. Currently your actions on Earth are afforded points, where every act has different point creditation. All morally good acts have positive points (saving a life, donating to charities, sacrificing your share for someone else), whereas your points get cut due to any negative actions (lying, cheating, stealing). Currently, if your motivations are corrupt, self serving, you don't get points for otherwise seemingly positive actions.
THO the centrality of sports in national identity
Open_Quarter
THW impose rental caps in urban hubs (san Francisco, Mumbai, Manhattan)
Open_Semi
In countries with largely agrarian economies, THP governments providing higher quality utilities (seeds, equipment, irrigation facilities) over providing MSPs.
Open_Semi
Info slide
MSP means minimum support price which is an agricultural product price, set by the Government to purchase directly from the farmer.
THW allow citizens from specific localities to vote on whether big corporates should set up business operations in those regions
Open_Semi
THP World A to World B
Open_Final
Info slide
WORLD A: Familial Care Labour (Household chores, planning, setting up of homes, etc.) is seen as a service job just like any other, hence the government pays for performer of these services in the household. (For this debate, we assume a fixed person or group of persons is responsible for this care labour, and it is assumed that is their only service job, and these individuals are not employed elsewhere.). WORLD B: Familiar Care Labour is seen as an act personal to families and outside the realm of service. In this case, all individuals of a household partake in care labour. Individuals hence are not paid for familial care labour, and everyone is assumed to have jobs externally.
THS legal realism in jurisprudence
Open_Final
Info slide
Legal realism is the view that jurisprudence should primarily rely on empirical evidence. It shifts the attention from written law codes and legal systems to a social relations based approach. Legal realism moves away philosophical inquiries into the nature and meaning of the law that are separate and distinct from the law as it is actually practiced. For example, when a court is asked to decide whether a harmful business activity is a common-law NUISANCE, the judge must ascertain whether the particular activity is reasonable. The judge does not base this determination on a precise determination of the written law and its principle. Instead, the judge balances the competing economic and social interests of the parties, and rules in favor of the litigant with the most persuasive case based on evidence.
TH, as citizens of a developing country, would actively choose to practice stoicism
Open_Final
Info slide
Stoicism is a school of virtue ethics, asserting that the practice of virtue is both necessary and sufficient to achieve happiness. Stoics also upheld indifference to wealth, and external stimuli, however also recognized that individuals could prefer to pursue the same only when it helped them live more virtuous lives.
Rahat Fundraiser 2021 (32 motions)
THO the trope of the strong mother
Open_Final
Info slide
the strong mother trope shows mothers as self reliant in the face of difficulty and who make great personal sacrifices for their children. Media frequently associates this with single mothers or mothers who have emigrated from their country of origin
TH, as feminists, opposes the lifting of the One Child Policy (Two Child, Three Child)
Open_Final
Info slide
On June 1st, China instated the Three Child Policy, allowing families to have up to three children, after previously replacing the One Child Policy with the Two Child Policy.
THR the dominance of emotionality in media representations of and discussions of girls
Open_Final
Info slide
https://youtu.be/gNi_6U5Pm_o?t=56 context pic screenshot of this headline
TH, as the anti-ableist movement, would center their narrative on the unique skills and abilities of people with disabilities, rather than their unique vulnerabilities
Open_Y
Given the existing technology, THW allow individuals to implant in themselves a computer chip with the AI algorithm
Open_Y
Info slide
AI processes datasets of human facial and verbal cues and uses it to develop an algorithm so that they automatically mimic what we perceive as appropriate emotional responses.
In rationing life-saving medical care, THW use the standard of preventability of condition by the individual, rather than quality of life or survivability
Open_Y
THS the rise of groups like Shubhamastu.
Open_Quarter
Info slide
Context 1'Shubhamastu', a Kolkata-based collective led by four priestesses, has been presiding over Hindu ceremonies of weddings, memorial services, housewarming rituals, among others, for over a decade now. These women have created simplified versions of Vedic ('from the Vedas') rituals and chants, and by subverting or doing away with some patriarchal rituals, they hope to elbow their way into what has been a male dominated space. Context 2 The group has however, been criticised for not having a single non-Brahmin (Brahmins are the highest-ranked caste in the Hindu caste system) priestess and for not stepping outside the universe of the Vedas. The rituals conducted by these priestess include the chanting of Sanskrit hymns and the performance of Rabindranath Tagore's vast repertoire of songs. note: the Vedas are a collection of four books that together form the corpus of Hindu literature. The Vedas have been criticised by stalwarts of the anti-caste movement like B.R Ambedkar for consolidating the superiority of the caste system.
THS churches taking an active role in brokering transitions of political power
Open_Quarter
Info slide
In Haiti, the Church offered to help broker discussions between the opposition and government for transitional elections after the dissolution of the goverment during unrest over contested extensions of terms in office.
THBT the Catholic Church has an obligation to publicly condemn the Nicaraguan presidency
Open_Quarter
Info slide
The Nicaraguan government has engaged in sweeping arrests of opposition leaders and the Organisation of American States is currently considering revoking its membership. The Vatican embassy has been engaged over the past year in trying to influence the governance of Ortega to promote political stability, as President Ortega and his wife are devout Catholics.
THBT it is illegitimate for states to enact policies seeking to alter the birthrate of its population
Open_Octa
TH, as a progressive academic in an authoritarian state, would advocate for progressive ideas as advancing state interests or policies
Open_Octa
THW retroactively apply environmental laws and regulations to corporations
6
THBT environmentalists should emphasize blaming large corporations for environment degradation, as opposed to focusing on individual responsibility
6
TH, as a developing nation, Would adopt domestic and regional policies to combat climate change rather than participate in global initiatives
6
THW keep historic artifacts and art at their point of discovery
5
TH, as a researcher who discovers that a nationally treasured artwork is a counterfeit W not report it
5
Info slide
A Rembrandt held at the University of Pretoria was recently found to be a forgery. The painting had been owned by 14 different buyers and described as "surely authentic" in a volume of Dutch paintings of the 17th century.
THBT creators should refuse to produce art in states that censor the representation of marginalised identities in art
5
Info slide
Hungary's parliament last week outlawed the portrayal of content featuring gay or transgender people. Similarly, the Hays Code in 1930s India outlawed the portrayal of LGBTQ characters except as villains.
THR the use of sanctions as a tool to bring about political change
4
THBT France should militarily intervene in Mali
4
Info slide
Mali fell under French colonial rule in 1893, up until 1960 where after active resistance it had its first President as an independent country. Last month, Mali's transitional president and prime minister were arrested by members of Mali's military, hours after a cabinet reshuffle which left out two supporters of the junta who had seized power in September. West Africa's ECOWAS bloc has called for the immediate release of President Bah N'Daw and Prime Minister Moctar Ouane and urged its transitional government "to resume its course and conclude within the established timeframe."
THBT the IMF should freeze return on investment payments to wealthy countries that hoard vaccines (retain more vaccines than are necessary to fully vaccinate their population)
4
THBT labour unions in developing countries should primarily pursue legislative change as a means of achieving workers' rights, instead of directly negotiating with companies
3
THW require the consent of local communities for the construction of national/transnational infrastructure placed through them
3
THW bar the acquisition of virtual reality and gaming companies by Facebook
3
Info slide
This month, Facebook bought Big Box VR and Unit 2 games. It already owned Beat Games, Sanzaru Games, and Ready at Dawn, as well as the Oculus platform. All are VR games.
THP a world without life altering events
2
TH supports the glorification of mediocre life
2
THP guilt society over shame society
2
Info slide
Guilt society and shame society are terminology for different categories of culture. In a guilt society, behaviour is guided by the internal self-reinforcement of the feeling of guilt for certain proscribed behaviours. This type of culture also emphasises individual conscience, faith, and values. A person in this type of culture may ask, "Do I feel my behaviour fair or unfair?" In a shame society, behaviour is guided by the inculcation of external shame (and the complementary threat of ostracism by the society). Shame cultures are typically based on the concepts of pride and honour, appearances are what count. A person in this type of culture may ask "How would people perceive me if I do X?"
THO virtual recreations of historic or cultural heritage sites
0
THO deceased artists being displayed by AI in concerts
0
THR the creation of art depicting social movements/oppressed communities by individuals not part of the community
0
THW adopt compulsory voting in developing nations
1
THW introduce an immediate democracy
1
Info slide
Immediate democracy is a system wherein voters have the ability change their vote at any given time, thus changing the composition of the parliament on a daily basis based on politicians' actions and public support
THP individuals voting on the basis on technocracy rather than ideology
1
Asia Schools Debate Championship 2021 (31 motions)
TH, as an HIV+ individual with an undetectable viral load, would not tell their prospective partners about their HIV status
Open_Z
Info slide
Recent studies suggest that a person living with HIV who is able to achieve an undetectable viral load status cannot transmit the virus to others through sexual contact. An undetectable viral load status can be maintained by taking antiretroviral drugs regularly.
THR the "born this way" narrative
Open_Z
Info slide
the "born this way" narrative suggests that an individual's sexual orientation and gender identity is something they are born with, thus rendering it innate and unchangeable. For decades, this perspective has been the rallying cry of the LGBTQ+ movement in order to advance political change and cultural acceptance.
TH as a mother will teach her daughter that "there are no good men"
Open_Z
THBT true women's liberation is incompatible with capitalism.
Novice_Final
THBT the transgender rights movement should distance itself instead of closely align with the feminist movement.
Novice_Final
THBT the feminist movement should actively encourage women to adopt traditionally "masculine" traits (eg assertiveness, being unemotional) to climb up the social ladder
Novice_Final
THS the creation and use of Lethal Autonomous Robots
Open_Semi
Info slide
Lethal autonomous weapon systems (LAWs) are a special class of weapon systems that use sensor suites and computer algorithms to independently identify a target and employ an onboard weapon system to engage and destroy the target without manual human control of the system. LAWs may operate in the air, on land, on water, under water, or in space
THO embedded journalism
Open_Semi
Info slide
Embedded journalism refers to the practice of placing journalists within and under the protection of one side's military during an armed conflict.
THW press the red button and end-all humankind.
Open_Semi
Info slide
There is a red button that if pressed, would end all of humankind. If it is not pressed, life will go on as it is for everyone.
THBT trade unions and labor protection laws should be suspended during times of economic crisis.
Open_Quarter
THP a world without credit ratings agencies
Open_Quarter
Info slide
A credit rating agency (CRA) evaluates and assesses an individual's or a company's creditworthiness. That is, these agencies consider a debtor's income and credit lines to analyse the debtor's ability to repay the debt or if there is any credit risk associated.
THW ban all countries that have a bad track record of human rights abuses from participating in all major international sporting events.
Open_Octa
THBT the IOC should strip awards of athletes on the basis of bad behavior
Open_Octa
Info slide
Currently, the only standard that the IOC follows in stripping medalists of their awards is if their actions compromise the integrity of competition. Examples include, but are not limited to, the use of banned drugs and violating amateurism rules. Klete Keller, a 5-time olympic medalist was charged with violating federal law for joining the riot on the US Capitol last January. There have been calls to have his medals stripped.
THS removing gender categories in all sporting events
Open_Octa
THBT micro-finance organisations (charities, NGOs, Development Banks) should offer micro-finance loans in developing nations only to women
6
Info slide
Micro-finance refers to longterm loans with little or low interest provided to individuals who seek to start a business.
THBT international organizations should make development aid conditional upon democratic reforms.
6
THBT post-conflict states should not instill nationalism through the education system
6
THW deny state-sponsored healthcare for those who refuse to get vaccinated
5
THW nationalise all housing
5
Info slide
Nationalise house refers to the government taking ownership and control of residential property, managing allocation, pricing, and more.
THW nationalise Facebook
5
THR the glorification of the narrative that "What does not kill you makes you stronger"
4
THR the narrative that lying is immoral
4
THR the rising trend in pop culture to portray villains as a victim of society
4
THP a world where psychological harms are perceived to be as severe as physical harms
3
THP a world in which individuals prioritized material happiness over immaterial happiness
3
THP a world in which individuals prioritized the pursuit of their own happiness over their families
3
THW decrease the burden of proof in sexual assault cases to a balance of probabilities rather than beyond a reasonable doubt
2
TH, as progressive activists in highly religious states, would make use of religious texts to justify progressive reform
2
THW ban the use of Smart Drugs for non-medical purposes in schools
1
Info slide
Smart drugs refer to drugs that improve the cognitive function of individuals, such as memory, creativity
THW give additional benefits to families on welfare whose children perform well in school
1
THBT job recruiters should remove all academic restrictions for job applications
1
People's Speak Invitational (12 motions)
THW remove nationalism from all school curriculums
1
Assuming a tradeoff is required, THBT history education in post-conflict societies should focus on reconciliation at the cost of truth
1
THR the emphasis placed on obtaining tertiary education
1
THS the use of primaries rather than internal elections to determine political party leadership.
2
Info slide
Primary elections, often abbrev. to primaries, are a process by which voters can indicate their preference for their party's candidate, in an upcoming general election, local election, or by-election
THR the valourisation of compromise politics in developing countries.
2
THW allow communities to veto resource mining projects in their local areas.
2
Info slide
Resource mining is the process of extracting useful materials from the earth. Some examples of substances that are mined include coal, gold, or iron ore.
THR the glorification of art produced for non-material gain
3
THBT artists should strive to portray the world as they believe it ought to be rather than as it is.
3
THO the prominence of " poptimism" in music criticism
3
Info slide
Poptimism is the belief that pop music is as worthy of professional analysis and interest as other genres of music (jazz, rock, classical) that have historically received such attention. Over the past two decades, music criticism has trended increasingly towards an embrace of poptimism. Examples of the prominence of poptimism include Rolling Stone (a historically rock focused magazine) naming Red by Taylor Swift the fourth best album of the entire 2010s.
THR the narrative patience is a virtue
4
THBT minority rights movements should prioritise an approach of arguing for equality and rights based on 'the need for legal equality as citizens of the state' as opposed to arguing for 'acceptance and assimilation of their identity'
4
THO the valourisation of "authenticity in popular culture"
4
Browse by topic instead
Motions are free. Judged rounds are the product.
Our students debate motions like these every week in full judged rounds, with oral adjudication and written feedback after every one.
Book a Consultation